/
Liquid Cooling Guide

Liquid Cooling Guide

This guide is provided as a reference for customers to simplify the selection process of appropriate cooling solutions for Flyway installations. Liquid cooling is optional, but recommended for demanding applications (e.g., operating at high power, achieving high precision movements, weighing payloads accurately).

Please see Flyway Cooling Setup for details on the installation.

image-20250109-202919.png

Maximum Pressure

Flyway max permissible coolant pressure is 340 kPa (50 PSI).

Untitled-20241219-212751.png

Many commonly available 10mm tubing options are only rated to 275 kPa (40 PSI) or lower. Failure to observe pressure ratings of selected tubing may result in personal injury or damage to property caused by rupture and rapid decompression of coolant lines.

Flow Coefficient and Steady State Temperature

The Flyway flow factor, Kv, has been experimentally measured at approximately 0.42 m3/h for 3-Series and 0.44 m3/h for 4-Series.

An estimate of the system’s flow rate can be calculated using the pressure drop across the Flyways and the flow factor, Kv, for each Flyway as follows:

image-20250114-003031.png

The following charts provide the projected flow rate through 3-Series and 4-Series Flyways connected in series for various pressure drop across the Flyway systems. These charts are only a projected flow rate, actual flow rate may vary depending on other components in line with your system and your specific pump’s capacity. For parallel cooling layouts, the projected flow rate can be estimated by multiplying the projected flowrate of each branch by the number of branches, assuming that each branch of the parallel layout contains the same number of Flyways.

image-20250109-215734.png
Projected flow rate for 3-Series Flyways in series
image-20250114-003340.png
Projected flow rate for 4-Series Flyways in series

The experimentally collected data in the graph below shows the measured steady-state temperature for different numbers of 3-Series Flyways in series with a small water chiller, with a least-squares best fit line applied. This data can provide a benchmark for system integrators when designing their cooling system. The chiller specifications and cooling liquid flowrate information is shown in the tables below. For the 16 Flyways in series and 8x2 Flyways in parallel test cases, the experimental chiller’s cooling capacity was saturated for power consumptions greater than 65 W per Flyway. If lower temperatures are required for the application parallel routing, increased liquid flowrates, and/or cooler input temperature should be implemented.

image-20250109-215918.png

Experimental Conditions

Water Chiller Data

     Nominal Cooling Capacity

1700 W

     Pump Power

48 W

     Compressor Power

0.75 kW

     Maximum Flow

16 L/min

Ambient Temperature

21 ⁰C

Cooling Liquid

Distilled water

Test Case

Liquid Flowrate [L/m]

Pressure Drop Across Flyways [kPa]

Liquid Input Temperature [°C]

1 Flyway in Series

5.0

74

18.5

2 Flyways in Series

4.4

92

18.5

4 Flyways in Series

3.7

112

18.6

8 Flyways in Series

2.8

126

19.1

16 Flyways in Series

2.1

147

19.5

2x8 Flyways in Parallel

3.8 (Total)

109

20.7

Condensation may occur on a cooled system if the system's surface temperature is below the dew point temperature of the air around the system. The dew point temperature depends on the humidity and ambient temperature and can be determined using the following chart. For example, for an ambient temperature of 20°C and a relative humidity of 70%, the dew point temperature is approximately, 14°C. The input temperature of the cooling liquid should therefore be set higher than 14°C to remove the chance of condensation. Integrators may also consider dehumidifying the ambient air to eliminate condensation.

image-20250109-220200.png

Thermal Load Estimation

The thermal load of a system can be estimated using either of the following methods:

  1. Compute from maximum rated capacity of system’s power supply(s)

    • The average power consumption of a Planar Motor system typically does not exceed half the rated power of the system’s AC/DC power supplies

    • Assume required cooling capacity is approximately equal to average power consumption 

  1. Compute from experimental results

    • Use the “Get Flyway Physical Status” function in Planar Motor Tool to obtain instantaneous Flyway power consumption of any given Flyway in the system

    • Record instantaneous power consumption of all Flyways during typical operation. Estimate required cooling capacity as equal to the cumulative instantaneous power consumption of all Flyways

For both methods, note that the chiller should have a maximum cooling capacity sufficiently above the actual thermal load of the system. If the thermal load approaches the chillers’ maximum capacity, an unacceptably high coolant temperature rise may occur. Choose a chiller with an oversized cooling capacity to avoid this problem.

Suitable Chillers for Common Applications

There are many chillers on the market which are suitable for cooling various sized Flyway systems. The table below contains examples of some chillers that are readily available. It is up to the customer to decide which chiller is suitable for their specific application: 

Product

Cost [USD]*

Cooling Capacity [W]

Notes

Max Flyways**

Configuration

Product

Cost [USD]*

Cooling Capacity [W]

Notes

Max Flyways**

Configuration

Vevor CW5200

~400

1400

Accuracy ±1°C

20

5 branches of 4 in series

SMC – HRS012-A-20-T

~4000

1100

Temperature stability 0.1°C

20

5 branches of 4 in series

Thermofisher TF-900

Request quote

900

Temperature stability 0.1°C

16

4 branches of 4 in series

Pfannenberg CCE 6101

Request quote

1100

Accuracy ±2°C

20

5 branches of 4 in series

* Subject to change

** Max Flyway estimate is based on typical system loading of 50W per Flyway-mover pair, and chiller-specific considerations

Select a chiller based on analysis of cooling capacity, coolant temperature accuracy requirements, and budget.

Suitable Chiller Fluids for Common Applications

Flyway materials internally exposed to coolant include:

  • C3604 brass

  • 6061 aluminum

  • 304 stainless steel

  • Polymers

    • PBT

    • PP

    • POM

    • NBR

EuroTerm 131 is a recommended coolant solution because it prevents corrosion of the cooling system.

For small, or temporary installations, various fluids may be acceptable (e.g., ethylene glycol-based fluids, water, etc..).

Feedback and Comments

Please email us at tech.portal@planarmotor.com